Steeby vs Fial Essay

Steeby vs Fial Essay

Do Not Copy. Order Custom, Original Paper.

Tort Liability Charles Fial and Roger J. Steeby entered into a partnership called Audit Consultants to perform auditing services. Pursuant to the agreement, they shared equally the equity, income, and profits of the partnership. Originally, they performed the auditing services themselves, but as business increased, they engaged independent contractors to do some of the audit work. Fial’s activities generated approximately 80 percent of the partnership’s revenues. Unhappy with their agreement to divide the profits equally, Fial wrote a letter to Steeby 7 years later, dissolving the partnership. Fial asserted that the clients should be assigned based on who brought them into the business.

Fial formed a new business called Audit Consultants of Colorado, Inc. He then terminated the original partnership’s contracts with many clients and put them under contract with his new firm. Fial also terminated the partnership’s contracts with the independent-contractor auditors and signed many of these auditors with his new firm. The partnership terminated about 11 months after Fial wrote the letter to Steeby. Steeby brought an action against Fial, alleging breach of fiduciary duty and seeking a final accounting. Who wins? Steeby v. Fial, 765 P.2d 1081, Web 1988 Colo.App. Lexis 409 (Court of Appeals of Colorado) PARTIES

In the Steeby vs. Fial case Roger Steeby is the plaintiff and Charles Fial is the defendant. Steeby and Fial formed a partnership at will to perform auditing services. CASE SUMMARY (FACTS) Pursuant to the agreement, equity, income, and profits of the partnership were shared equally. In the infancy stage of the partnership they conducted audit services themselves.

As business success started to trend upwards they decided to employ independent contractors (auditors) to assist in performing audit service. Eventually the auditors were carrying out the audits while the partners focus shifted to supervision and prospecting new clients. Fial’s ability to solicit new business was superior and in fact generated about 80% of revenue while Steeby was responsible for the other 20%. Unhappy with the current profit sharing arrangement Fial issued a letter to Steeby dissolving the partnership.

The letter claimed since there was “no common property and no common liabilities,” the separation should “should merely involve the assignment of accounts.” Fial believed the partners would be entitled to the profits brought in by the clients they successfully solicited new business from. Fial proceeded to terminate the contracts of the auditors and the partnership clients. He then signed the clients to a new firm he formed Audit Consultants of Colorado, he also hired many of the auditors previously employed to work under his new firm. The partnership was officially terminated 11 months from the time Fial issued his letter. PROCEDURE

Steeby filed an action against Fial for breach of the partnership agreement and for a final accounting of all partnership assets. The trial court determined that Fial had violated the partnership agreement by breaching a fiduciary duty he owed to Steeby. This a duty where one is not to act a way having conflicting interests. The first manner in which Fial had breached his fiduciary duty was by terminating the auditors, therefore dispersing partnership assets. He also terminated contracts with partnership clients, and signed the auditors to work on audit engagements that belonged to the partnership under his new firm. A receiver was appointed by the court a to issue a final accounting and distribution of all partnership property and assets (

Fial disagrees with the court’s ruling on his breach of fiduciary duty during prior to partnership termination. However partners are fiduciaries to each other. Partners share a fiduciary relation to one another in all matters concerning the partnership. The “partnership relation is one of trust, loyalty and confidence. It imposes upon the partners the highest standards of good faith, the duty to act for the common benefit of all partners in all transactions relating to the business and the duty to refrain from taking any advantage of one another by the slightest misrepresentation, concealment, threat or adverse pressure of any kind” (

There should also be full disclosure and continuous obligation amongst partners. The issue is did Fial act in good faith as a fiduciary? The dissipation of a business or partnership in this case usually goes through proceeds through three steps which are: dismantling: dissolution, winding up, and termination. Dissolution occurs when there is a change in ownership, this results in new accounting entity (Delaney, Borke, Baker, McDougard, Simon & Smith, 2000 p.665).

The dissolution does not terminate the partnership immediately, rather it goes through the wind up stage until are affairs have been resolved. Upon the completion of winding up, the partnership is thereby terminated. In the wind up stages Steeby and Fial agreed that the auditors would be told that the partnership was being dissolved but that they were to continue their work on partnership accounts ( HOLDING

Fial’s actions of contracting the auditors and clients of the partnership on behalf of the his new firm violated the his duty of loyalty. The courts had correctly determined that Fial had breached his fiduciary duty to Steeby by not disclosing the termination of the contracts with the auditors and partnership client. He also renegotiated the contracts for his own personal gain. REASONING

Following the dissolution of a partnership, both partners continue to have a fiduciary duty to the other partner that continues until the partnership assets have been divided and the liabilities have been satisfied. A partner should not engage in activities any action with respect to unfinished partnership business which leads to purely personal gain ( Also, a partner completing unfinished partnership business cannot extinguish the rights of the other partners in the dissolved partnership by the tactic of entering into a “new” contract to complete such business (

The court was correct in its initial ruling determining that Fial had breached a fiduciary obligation by dissipating the assets of the partnership and by refusing to account for their value during the period of winding up (www. CONCLUSION

Fial contends that, even if he breached a fiduciary duty, Steeby suffered no harm, and thus, the trial court ruled incorrectly by calculating and awarding damages. The courts concluded the only fair way to asses Steeby’s lost profits was to assign a value to the auditors and existing partnership

  • StudyAcer

  • Trustpilot

  • Sitejabber


Need help with writing Steeby vs Fial Essay?

Get help


Writer avatar

Rating: 4.9/5    Reviews 373

Success rate 99%

Completed projects: 592

Hello, I am a full-time professional freelance writer with over 6 years experience in academic writing. I have a PhD in Strategic Management and have done several projects in business management, marketing and other subjects. This experience has helped me reinforce my ability to work in various fields and handle simple and complex topics. I am a...

Writer avatar

Rating: 5/5    Reviews 1326

Success rate 100%

Completed projects: 1976

Hello :) My name is Dr.Success, I've started on my path as a professional writer mostly by writing essays. However, in the years since then, I've written various other academic papers, from research works to book reviews. From Sydney to New York, there are hundreds of students all over the world that are happy with the services I've provided the...

Writer avatar

Rating: 5/5    Reviews 371

Success rate 99%

Completed projects: 1173

Hi there! Im MarvellousTutor, your perfect author with huge writing experience in English, Art and Business. What? Need assignment on another subject? No worries: I can deal with anything! If you're dreaming of the reliable, responsible and always-on-time writer, here I am! I manage my time greatly, thus, your deadline is highly important for me...

Writer avatar

Rating: 4.7/5    Reviews 891

Success rate 98%

Completed projects: 1136

Hello there! My name is Prof Stephen. I have been a full-time freelance researcher and writer for a period of over 6 years. I have successfully completed over 1000 projects and assignments. I have had a good professional relationship with my clients who always come back for more quality papers since I highly value quality, professionalism, and i...

Writer avatar

Rating: 4.9/5    Reviews 244

Success rate 96%

Completed projects: 479

I'm ProfTzKelly, talented wordsmith, grammar afficionado, and writing machine. I'm written everything from outlines to screenplays and book reviews to advanced research papers. All you have to do to be well on your way to a great grade is chat with me! I'm experienced in all major styles, including APA, MLA, Chicago, Harvard, and Vancouver. You ...

Writer avatar

Rating: 5/5    Reviews 465

Success rate 98%

Completed projects: 852

Hey! My name is ProfAcer, and my goal is to help you to get through a tough period of your life. I've been a student, and I know that the amount of work some professors expect you to do can be unfair and overwhelming. And that's without even accounting for the job you probably have an active social life each student should have. There is no sham...

Writer avatar

Rating: 4.9/5    Reviews 412

Success rate 96%

Completed projects: 719

In academic writing, quality, originality, and deadlines are vital, and these are my primary offerings to all my clients. I have two years of experience as a full-time academic writer, with over 300 finance, economics, marketing, business, and general papers written from scratch. Since joining this site, I have also tackled sociology, healthcare...

Writer avatar

Rating: 5/5    Reviews 482

Success rate 96%

Completed projects: 783

Hello, I am Prof Writers, I am a bold, accurate, and experienced tutor committed to providing clients with high quality, original, and timely work. As a writer, proficiency in several disciplines in academic writing is necessary, and that is why I prioritize on delivering quality and appropriate work. Be assured that I will always follow the lai...

Writer avatar

Rating: 4.8/5    Reviews 319

Success rate 97%

Completed projects: 584

Hello! People call me ThinkTank, and I've been earning money as an academic writer for years. With a lot of works under my belt, you can bet that I've dealt with dozens of various topics and different forms of papers, including essays, research papers, and even dissertations. I like the challenge that comes with this job. I first fell in love wi...